Shopify Themes: How to Choose the Right One

Your Shopify theme determines how your store looks and feels to customers. It controls the layout, colors, typography, and overall shopping experience. Choosing the right theme is one of the most important decisions you'll make when setting up your store. This guide covers what to look for and how to evaluate your options.

What Is a Shopify Theme?

A theme is a template that controls your store's design:

  • Visual design: Colors, fonts, spacing, and imagery
  • Layout: How pages are structured and organized
  • Features: Built-in functionality like slideshows, product filters, or quick buy
  • Mobile experience: How your store appears on phones and tablets

Free vs. Paid Themes

Free Themes

Shopify offers several free themes designed in-house:

  • Dawn: The default OS 2.0 theme, fast and minimal
  • Craft: Designed for artisan and handmade products
  • Refresh: Clean layout for health and beauty stores
  • Sense: Focused on storytelling and brand narrative
  • Ride: Built for sports and outdoor product stores
  • Taste: Optimized for food and beverage stores

Pros: No cost, well-supported, regular updates from Shopify.

Cons: Fewer features and customization options than paid themes.

Paid Themes

The Shopify Theme Store offers paid themes from third-party developers, typically $180-$350:

  • More built-in features (mega menus, advanced filtering, etc.)
  • Greater customization flexibility
  • Industry-specific designs
  • Developer support included

What to Look for in a Theme

1. Mobile Responsiveness

Most e-commerce traffic comes from mobile devices. Ensure your theme:

  • Test the theme demo on your phone — check product image galleries, add-to-cart buttons, and the slide-out cart
  • Verify the mobile navigation handles your category depth (Dawn uses a collapsible menu, some paid themes offer mega menus on mobile)
  • Check mobile checkout flow — Shopify's checkout is standard across themes, but the path to checkout varies by theme

2. Page Speed

Slow-loading stores lose customers. Look for themes that:

  • Check the theme's Lighthouse score in the Shopify Theme Store listing — Shopify publishes speed scores for all themes
  • Fewer built-in sections means faster initial load — a theme with 40 homepage sections will be slower than one with 10
  • Avoid themes that load heavy JavaScript libraries (jQuery, Slick Slider) when native CSS alternatives exist

3. Built-in Features

Consider which features you need:

  • Product filtering: Help customers narrow options
  • Quick buy: Add to cart without leaving the page
  • Mega menus: Display many categories in navigation
  • Promotional banners: Highlight sales and announcements
  • Customer reviews: Display product reviews

4. Collection Display Options

How products appear in collections matters:

  • Grid layout options (2, 3, or 4 columns)
  • Filtering and sorting capabilities
  • Product card customization (what info shows on hover)
Optimize Your Collections: Once you've chosen a theme, AWSM Collections helps you organize products into well-structured collections that display beautifully in any theme.

5. Customization Options

Evaluate how much you can customize without coding:

  • Color scheme options
  • Font choices
  • Section arrangements
  • Header and footer options

Evaluating Themes

Preview the Demo

Every theme has a demo store. When previewing:

  1. Browse like a customer would
  2. Test on your phone as well as desktop
  3. Check product pages, collection pages, and cart
  4. Try the navigation and search

Read Reviews

Theme Store reviews reveal real user experiences:

  • Look for comments about ease of customization
  • Note any recurring issues mentioned
  • Check how the developer responds to problems

Check Developer Support

Themes require updates and occasional troubleshooting:

  • How long has the developer been active?
  • How recently was the theme updated?
  • What support channels are available?

Installing a Theme

  1. Go to Online Store > Themes in your Shopify admin
  2. Click Add theme
  3. Choose from free themes or visit the Theme Store
  4. After adding, click Customize to configure
  5. Preview your changes before publishing

Customizing Your Theme

Theme Editor

The visual editor lets you customize without code:

  • Add, remove, and reorder sections
  • Change colors, fonts, and spacing
  • Configure header, footer, and navigation
  • Set up the homepage layout

Code Editing

For advanced customization, you can edit theme files directly:

  • Liquid files: Template logic and structure
  • CSS/SCSS: Styling and appearance
  • JavaScript: Interactive functionality

Tip: Always duplicate your theme before editing code, so you can revert if needed.

Theme SEO Considerations

A well-built theme supports SEO best practices:

  • Clean, semantic HTML structure
  • Proper heading hierarchy (H1, H2, etc.)
  • Schema markup for products and reviews
  • Fast page load speeds
  • Mobile-first responsive design

Common Theme Mistakes

  • Choosing based only on looks: Features and performance matter too
  • Ignoring mobile preview: Most customers shop on phones
  • Over-customizing: Too many changes can cause issues with updates
  • Not testing checkout: The buying process must work smoothly

Conclusion

Your theme sets the foundation for your store's customer experience. Choose one that matches your brand, includes the features you need, performs well on mobile, and comes from a reputable developer. Start with the basics and customize as you learn what works for your customers.

Related Resources

Disclaimer: While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, we cannot guarantee the correctness of all content.
Information may be outdated or incorrect, and we recommend verifying any information before relying on it.